Also Known As West Creek New Lisbon, Otsego County, NY Read 6-11-1985 Virginia Schoradt Re-Typed by Annette Campbell |
Located on County Route 11 on the farm of Tracy & William Balcom. Cemetery surrounded by farm type fence which is in fairly good shape. Cemetery itself is unmowed and there are stones which are down and/or broken and no longer readable. Condition: Fair. Previous reading in 1935 by D.A.R. Several stones are now missing. Caleb Aspinwall d. 18 Mar 1841 Age 50y7m Capt. Amos Barton d. 24 Mar 1874 Age 75y Betsey Barton d. 20 Sep 1882 Age 78y Wife of Amos Phebe Ann Barton d. 4 Aug 1834 Age 14y Dau of Amos & Betsey Sally J. Barton d. 28 Sep 1852 Age 19y Dau of Amos & Betsey Anna Barton d. 23 Mar 1862 Age 76y Wife of Robert Rowland Barton d. 11 Apr 1832 Age 4y Son of William & Lois Zebulon Barton d. 3 Jul 1867 Age 39y Peter Cooley d. 6 Sep 1839 Age 69y Mary F. Cooley d. 29 Dec 1869 Age 85y Wife of Peter (Stone not found in 1985 reading) Job Eldred d. 2 Mar 1814 Age 70y Mercy Eldred d. 6 Jun 1823 Age 74y Wife of Job Phebe Eldred d. 16 Dec 1817 Age 24y Wife of Potter Frendy Eldred d. 11 Mar 1824 Age 19y Dau of Daniel & Olive Harvey Eldred 13 Aug 1799-24 Jan 1872 Hannah Eldred 8 Apr 1800-1 Sep 1873 Wife of Harvey Hannah Eldred d. 8 Feb 1832 Age 57y Wife of Deacon Nathan Stukely Elsworth, Esq. d. 31 Mar 1837 Age 67y (Stone not found in 1985 reading) Mariam Fitch, twin d. 18 Jan 1811 Age 19d Dau of William & Susan Anngeline Fitch, twin d. 18 Jan 1811 Age 19d Dau of William & Susan Abram Gardner d. 11 Apr 1851 Age 29y Benjamin Gardner d. 27 Apr 1846 Age 36y Polly Gardner d. 29 Jun 1883 Age 70y Wife of Benjamin (Stone not found in 1985 reading) Edgar Gardner d. 22 Dec 1839 Age 2y5m9d Son of Asa & Nancy Hulda Gardner d. 7 Dec 1831 Age 2y Dau of Rufus & Lucinda Franklin P. Gardner d. 22 Mar 1861 Age 13y1m Son of Aurelius F. & Phebe Leroy Gardner d. 29 Nov 1828 Ae 1y Son of Rufus & Lucinda Nancy Gardner d. 2 Nov 1853 56y5m3d Dau of George & Mary Laura Gardner d. 28 May 1860 Age 13y Amy Gardner 28 Feb 1841-3 Sep 1842 Dau of Benjamin & Polly William Gardner d. 19 Apr 1851 Age 14y Son of Benjamin & Polly George Gardner d. 19 Apr 1851 Age 74y Mary Gardner d. 9 Jul 1842 Age 59y Wife of George Lucinda Gardner d. 26 Aug 1846 Age 42y Wife of Rufus Warren Gardner d. 27 May 1841 Age 3y Son of ?? Amy Gardner d. 2 Jan 1868 Age 74y (Stone not found in 1985 reading) Nathaniel Gardner d. 18 Apr 1858 Age 80y (Stone not found in 1985) Adaline Gilbert d. 7 Jan 1856 Age 27y1m11d Wife of Delos Lielis Gilbert d. 6 Apr 1864 Age 26y 2nd Wife of Delos Delos Gilbert 3 Jul 1826-8 May 1887 (Stone not found in 1985 reading) Georgie Gilbert d. 18 May 1866 Age 2y Son of Delos & Lielis Morris Gilbert d. 18 Apr 1860 Age 63y Olive Gilbert d. 2 Dec 1886 Age 84y Wife of Morris Lloyd Gilbert d. 11 Dec 1845 Age 23y Son of Morris & Olive Milton D. Gilbert No data Son of Delos & Betsey Sylvester Gilbert d. 7 Mar 1842 Age 5 months Son of Morris & Olive William Gilbert d. 28 Nov 1838 Son of Morris & Olive Hannah Harrington d. 18 Aug 1833 Age 63y Wife of Job Amy Harrington d. 12 Jul 1858 Age 88y1m Stanton Harrington d. 16 Jun 1843 Age 19y Son of Truman & Adra Josephine Harrington d. 14 Sep 1854 Age 1y2m27d Stephen Herrington d. Jan 1812 Age 71y Patience Herrington d. 22 Jan 1812 Age 68y Wife of Stephen James Herrington d. 23 Nov 1813 Age 48y Mrs. Mary Herrington d. 22 Jun 18?? (looks like 23) Age ?? Wife of James Stephen Herrington d. 16 ___ 1813 Age 19?y Son of James & Mary Waity Johnson d. 29 Apr 1847 Age 75y Wife of Thomas Daughter of Stephen & Patience HERRINGTON Thomas Johnson d. 10 Oct 1860 Age 93y (Stone not found in 1985 reading) Schuyler Morell Mann 29 Apr 1831 Age 3y Son of Ephraim M. & Eliza Mary Marsh d. 22 Jul 1844 Age 89y Widow of Samuel Eliza C. Martin d. 30 Aug 1820 Age 23y Wife of Rev. Edward W. Antonette M. McDonald d. 18 Apr 1858 Age 33y Wife of John James Meyers d. 23 Aug 1828 Age 17y Son of Henry & Amy John Meyers d. 31 Mar 1828 Age 58y Patience Platt d. 4 Jun 1851 Age 22y Wifew of Garrett Truman Root d. 29 Nov 1879 Age 91y Elvira Root d. 10 Jul 1826 Age 34y Wife of Truman Rhoda B. Rous d. 20 Oct 1842 Age 27y Wife of Benjamin _____ Sargent d. 1 Apr 1883 Age 2m8d Son of Marshall Sargeant & Mary A Pickens Albertus M. Spencer 12 Oct 1820-13 Apr 1894 Mary Stanton d. 5 Nov 1858 Age 87y Wife of Thomas Thomas S. Stanton d. 6 Nov 1844 Age 79y Mary L. Weeks d. 4 Oct 1854 Age 2y3m24d Dau of Peter & Laura George Yates d. 7 Aug 1824 Age 40y Elizabeth Yates d. 10 Jul 1858 Age 74y Wife of George Additional readings from Lealah M. Smith an earlier GAR list found in the State Library in Albany, NY Charles M. Gilbert d. 11 May 1885 Age 31y6m0d Son of Delos W & Lillas Jennie Gilbert d. Mar 1860 Age 1y Dau of Delos W & Lillas Wilton D. Gilbert d. 9 Jul 1859 Age 1y9m2d Son of Delos W. & Betsey Addie M. Gilbert d. 3 Apr 1878 Age 1y3m8d Dau of Delos W. & Betsey ______ Gilbert rest of stone illegible Nathaniel Gardner d. 10 Nov 1855 Age 32y Son of Nathaniel & Nancy Caroline Gardner d. 25 Nov 1876 Age 43y Dau of Asa & Nancy James Harrington d. 23 Nov 1813 Age 48y Mary Harrington d. 22 Jun 1823 Age 56y Wife of James (nee SPENCER) Truman Harrington d. 8 Jan 1839 Age 3 months Son of Truman & Adra Infant Son Harrington Dates on stone not clear Son of Truman & Adra Stephen Harrington d. 10 Feb 1830 Age 5y Son of Solomon Silvanus Harrington d. 10 Jul 1830 Age 6y Son of Solomon James Aylesworth No stone "Said to be buried here" His wife Margaret HARRINGTON Aylesworth is buried at West Amboy, Oswego Co, NY & were my ancestors--Lealah M. Smith, Bainbridge, NY George Card d. 19 Apr 1851 Age 74y Mary Card d. 9 Jul 1842 Age 59y Wife of George Nathaniel Clark d. 10 Jul 1825/28 Age 64y Nancy Clark d. 11 Jun 1820 Age 55y Wife of Nathaniel (nee AYLESWORTH) Morris Gregory No data Thirza Harrington d. 22 Feb 1843 Age 31y4m4d Wife of Riley (Said to be buried here, died while on a visit to her relatives, no stone found) Samuel Gardner 16 Apr 1822- ??? Mary Gardner d. 14 Mar 1880 Age 58y Wife of Samuel (probably a JACOBS) Oscar A. Gradner d. 20 Oct 1844 Age 1y3m15d Son of Samuel & Mary Mary dau ___________ Mary Gardner d. 9 Jul 1842 Age 50y Wife of George (said to be a dau of Nathaniel & Nancy CLARK) Mary Marsh d. 22 Jul 1844 Age 89y0m19d Widow of Samuel