Old Chappel Burying Ground
Fly Creek, Otsego County, NY
Inscriptions read by Florence Michaels and Marjorie Willsey in 1973
Research by Harriet Rogers
Typed by Marion Brophy


This cemetery is located .4 mile north of the flashing light in Fly Creek, it is located 
at intersection of Hoke Street and County Route 26.These lists are a composite of burial 
records and tombstone inscriptions.  Many stones and missing and lost since the cemetery 
was first started in the late 1790s.
ALDEN            Juliann,  daughter of William and Sara,  Died Sept.30, 1828 in her 16th year

ALLEN             Ezra,  Died July 14, 1861  Age 61

     “                   Lydia,  wife of Ezra W   Died March 8,  1882,  Age 73 

     “                   Ruth Leontine,  daughter of Ezra W. and Lydia   Died Sept. 16, 1861  

                                    Age 24

     “                   Steven,   Died  Feb. 27, 181(5?)   Age  (61)

     “                   Lydia,  wife of Stephen   Died May 12, 1864, Age 78 years, 11 months

 

ANDERSON    Lemuel    Died Feb. 16, 1815   Age 80

      “                  Rachel,  wife of  Lemuel,  Died June 9, 1860,  Age 92 years, 11 days

 

AYRES            Phyann,  wife of  Wm. Ayres,   Died Sept.7, 1848   Aged 27 years

 

 

 

BABBITT        Elkannah   Died Feb.9, 1807 in his 70th year

      “                 Rachael,  consort of Elkannah   Died Feb. 9,1815 in her 78th year

      “                 Sarah,   wife of Warren    Died Jan. 2, 1861

                        Warren,   Died July 4, 1847   Age 73 years, 14 days

 

BADGER         Major John,   Died Nov.16, 1833  in the 60th year of his age

      “                 Orestes,   Died Oct 1850,  Aged 58 

                        Naomi H.,  daughter of Orestes and Polly Badger,  Died  Feb.28, 1836

      “                 Polly  VANDERCOOK.  wife of Orestes   Died  July 9, 1861  62 years

 

BAILEY          Charles   Died  Sept.8, 1826 in the 75th year of his age

      “                 Sarah  wife of Charles   Died Sept 13, 1826 in the 71st year of her age

      “                 John,   Died Feb.15, 1858  aged 74 years, 3 months, 7 days

     “                  Mary,  wife of Roger   Died  May 26, 1872  71 years, 10 mo., 20 days

     “                  Roger   Died Feb.1, 1863,  75 years, 2 months, 12 days

            

BALDWIN      Abner,   Died Dec.2, 1834  Age 78 years, 28 days, was in Revolution

      “                 John,   Died Jan. 27, 1862  Age 72 years, 9 months

      “                 Julia, wife of John   Died May 5, 1878,  90 years, 2 months, 15 days

      
BALDWIN      George William,   Died April 7, 1857  Age 31 years

      “:                Everett, son of L.W. and Amanda,  Died Sept.27, 1872,  age 22 days

 

BALL              Elizabeth,   Died Oct.18, 1825  89 years

 

BASSETT        Eunice, daughter of Samuel and Ann Bassett   Died May 11, 1856, 

                                    age 26 years

BEACH           David R   Died Dec.13, 1872,  age 51 years

     “                  Minerva, wife of David   Died March 5, 1834,  37 years

                        

BOZWORTH  Samuel C   Died June 2, 1842  in his 40th year

 

BROCKWAY   Hannah, wife of Levi Brockway   Died Oct.9, 1825,  Age 49 years

 

BROOKS        Diana W., wife of Asa Brooks,   Died Aug.9, 1825,  Age 30 years

     “                  Abel,  son of Cornelius and Hannah Brooks   Died March 31, 1877  

                                    Aged  87 years

     “                  Orra, wife of Abel  and daughter of John and Martha COLTON   Died 

                                    Dec.7, 1846   Aged 63 years

BROWNELL   Electa Ann, daughter of John &  Eliza WILLIAMS,  adopted daughter of 
R.& M. Brownell,  Died Dec. 19, 1855,  Age 12 years, 1 mo, 1 d

      “                 Mary Ann,  wife of Russel Brownell,   Died Nov.20, 1853,  Age 48 years, 

                                    3months, 23 Days

 

 

CAMP             Henry,   Died May 30, 1861  Age 50 years

     “                  Nancy PACKER, his wife   Died Nov.30, 1894,  Age 79

 

CHENEY        Ebenezer,    Died  Sept. 2, 1800   60 years  Nearby marker, “Corp’l                                        
Ebenezer Cheney,  Wyll’s Ct., Mil. Rev. War.”

     “                  Prissilla, wife of Ebenezer,   Died  Feb. 26, 1813, 72 years

     “                  Ebenezer, Jr.  Died March 10, 1803    34 years

 

CLARK           Harma, wife of John Clark,   Died Feb.1, 1860,  Age 68 years, 3 months,

                                    20 days

     “                  Hannah,    Died Jan.1, 1851   Age 50 years

     “                  Peter,   Died Dec.30, 1838   Age 69 years, 2 months

     “                  Ruth,  wife of Peter Clark,  Died May 25, 1843  Age 38 years  6 months

     “                  John,   Died March 28, 1873   Age 82 years

 

CLINTON       John,  1752-1832,  Soldier of Fifth N.Y. 1779 Willet’s Levies.  1781.  
Revolutionary War

     “                  Mary, wife of John Clinton,   Died Dec. 16, 1805, in her 57th year

 

COLEMAN     Dr. Noah,   Died 1801  (uncle of Robert J. Roberts)

 

COLTIS          Elizabeth A.,   Died Dec. 16, 1851

 

COOK                        Mary,   Died Oct. 30, 1860  Age 47 years 

 

CROSBY        John G.   Died March 28, 1850   Age 75 years

      “                 Joseph,   Died May 31, 1888  82 years

 

DENNIS          Almira G  wife of Oliver H. Dennis   Died Jan. 16, 1840 in the

                                    27th year of her age

 

DEWEY          Martha,   Died  Oct.23, 1834   Age  26 years

     “                  Robert,    Died  Jan. 12, 1839  in the 33rd year of his age

     “                  Truman    Died  May 26, 1851  Age 80 years 9 months

     “                  Abigal,  wife of Truman    Died  May 19, 1836

 

DRAKE           Chandler,   Died Jan.9,  1826  in his 20th year

 

 

EISLE              Anna, wife of Henry Eisle,   Died Aug.6, 1831  Age 69 years

 

 

FELLOW        Mercy, wife of Alexander,   Died 1840,  Age 58

 

FISKE,            Anna, wife of Henry Fiske,   Died Aug.5, 1854  Age 69 years

 

FOWLER        Lucinda, wife of S.W. Fowler   Died Dec.7, 1842  Aged 45 years                    

 

 

GALLUP         Celinda,  wife of Raymond Gallup,  Died Aug.31, 1851  Age 66 years

     “                  Deana W.,  daughter of  D.D. and S.M. Gallup   Died  March 18, 1842

                                    Age 1 year, 1 month, 15 days

     “                  Eliza A.,  wife of Loyd G. Gallup   Died Sept.6, 1850  Age 38 years, 9 mo.

 

GALPIN          Andrew Silas    Died Nov.21, 1825   Age 4 months

 

GOFF              Aurelia, wife of James Goff and daughter of Levi BROCKWAY   Died

                                    Feb.8, 1821,  Age 21 years

GREASY         Joseph   Died  May 31, 1888   Age 82 years

 

 

HALL              John,   Died  Dec.8, 1861

 

HECOX           Alexander,   Died Feb. 23, 1838,  Age 38 years

     “                  Albert, son of Daniel & Amy   Died March 6, 1852, 2 yrs,7 mo 19 da

     “                  Edwin, son of Daniel & Amy,   Died Feb.21, 1850. 5 years, 7 mo  

     “                  Elizabeth,  wife of Dr. Samuel Hecox,   Died  Sept.3, 1852   Age

                                    84 years, 3 months

     “                  Dr, Samuel,   Died  March 6, 1846  Age 96 years

 

HENRY           Adam,   Died June 16, 1838 in the 98th years of his age

     “                  Elizabeth,   Died Oct.16, 1838 in the 70th year of her life

     “                  Mary,   Died May 14, 1845  Aged 72 years

 

HERRINGTON  Susan Almira, wife of William Herrington.    Died Oct.31, 1870

                                    Age 34 years

HIGBY            John,   Died Feb.18, 1815 , buried elsewhere

     “                  Sarah   Died April, 12, 1812

     “                  William,   Died Nov.29, 1805

 

HODGE           Elizabeth,  wife of Spencer Hodge,   Died Sept. 21, 1846,  Aged 31 years, 

                                    4 months

HOOKER        Amorett L.   Died Sept.5, 1815  Age 1 year, 2 months

     “                  Emory L   Died March 9, 1838  Age 1 year, 2 months - children of  Horace 
C. and Sophia Hooker

HUBBELL       Jabez,    Died  Oct.1,  1836   Aged 78 years 

 

 

JOHNSON      Anna,  wife of James Johnson.   Died Sept.5, 1867  Age 70 years

     “                  James L    Died  April 10, 1846   Age 57 years

     “                  Erastus,  Son of James and Anna   Died Sept.7, 1837  Age 22 yrs,3 mo, 

     “                  Edward,    “         “          “     “       Died Sept.5, 1835  Age 22 yrs 3 mo 

     “                  Parley,   Died      4, 1817   

     “                  Clarissa,  wife of Parley Johnson,   Died July 26, 1835  Age 50 years

     “                  Clarence H., son of A.G. and  L.E.. Johnson       2 years 6 months

     “                  George    Died June 18, 1857  Age  44 years, 5 months,  24 days
     “                  Mary Ann,  wife of  William NORTHRUP, former wife of George 
Johnson,   Died Oct.19, 1874  Age  59 years  6 months  4 days

     “                  George   Died May 28, 1838   Age 85 years

     “                  Chloe, wife of George   Died  Jan 4, 1830   Age 82 years

     “                  Tabitha,  wife of George Johnson   Died May 21, 1814  in her 53d year

     “                  William   Died June 9, 1834  in his 48th year

     “                  Hannah, wife of William   Died May 1, 1843  Age 54 Years  3 months

     “                  Harriete,  wife of Col. William P. Johnson   Died Dec.5, 1840 in her 24th year

JONES            Samuel M    Died March 22, 1844   Age 66 years

 

KENYON       Olive   Died Feb.17, 1838    Age 10 years

 

KIBBETT        Electa  wife of Thomas    Died Jan.28, 1848   Age 57 years

 

KIBBY            Abilene, wife of Jacob   Died  Jan.15, 1861  Age 93 years  6 months

 

KING              Susan M  wife of Constantine    Died Aug.29, 1861 in 95th year

     “                  Mary A  TORRY, wife of Addison King   Nov.1, 1827 - Feb.2, 1894     

 

LANDERS      J. Landers   Died Oct.9, 1816

 

LANGLEY      Edward,   Died  Nov.19, 1836   Age  29 years

     “                  Elizabeth   Died  Jan. 31, 1831   Age  29 years

 

LEROW          Luella Medora, daughter of Alexander and Margaret.  Died July 31, 1851

                                    Age 3 years 8 months

     “                  Mercy, wife of Alexander   Died  Nov.14, 1845

 

LIPPITT          Nancy,  wife of Loudon   Died Feb. 22, 1826  in her 66th year

 

LITTLE            William   Died April 8, 1797  Age 42 years  “To whose memory this stone

                                    is erected by his surviving Consort Mrs. Keziah Little“

 

LUMLEY        Lydia    Died May 14, 1902   Age 83 years

 

MARVIN        Abraham    Died  May 1, 1825   Age 38 years

     “                  Mary,  wife of Abraham    Died  Nov. 13, 1838  in her 54th year

     “                  Daniel,   Born  May 18, 1789    Died  July 3, 1856

     “                  Orson, son of Daniel Marvin   Died  Nov. 11, 1818  Age 1 yr  9 mos. 11 d

     “                  Daniel, Jr.,  son of Daniel and Sarah   Died July 10, 1826  Age 15 yr 7 mo 

     “                  Sarah RUSSELL  wife of Daniel   Died  Nov.2, 1867  Age 74 years

     “                  David    Died  Feb. Feb. 17, 1855  Age 83 years

     “                  Sabrina G., 1st wife of David   Died  April 25,  1824  Age 48 years

     “                  Sarah,  daughter of David and Sabrina  Died  July 27, 1798  Age 1 yr 9 mo

     “                  Sons of David and Sabrina, age 5 weeks and 1 day,  died 1808 and 1809

     “                  Eleanor,  2d wife of David   Died  Oct.6, 1848  Age  76 years

     “                  Minerva, wife of Theodore    Died March 19, 1852  Age 23 years

     “                  Diane   Died July 3, 1856

     “                  John   Died  Jan. 22, 1845  Age 41 years 

     “                  Jane,  wife of John   Died May 24, 1833,  Age 32 years

     “                  John R   Died June 22, 1873

     “                  Hannah Jane,  dau. of John and Hannah   Died   May 9, 1884

MARVIN        Henry Edward,  son of John and Hannah    Died May 15, 18--

     “                  Mary Frances, dau of John & Nancy    Died July 23, 181?  7 mo 5 da

     “                  Sally Ann   Born .April 27, 1823    Died  Oct. 23, 1886?

     “                  William    Died  May 12, 1819   Age 24 years

 

MATTESON   Wanton G    Died  Aug. 24, 1876   Age 50 years

 

McKINNEY    David,. son of James & Catherine McKinney  Died Sept.11, 1827  16 yrs        

 

MERRILL        John,  Died  April 28, 1812  Aged 65 years

 

MILLER          Elizabeth  Died 1840

 

NILES             Gidean   Died  Jan.14, 1822,  Age 54 years

 

NORTH           Anne H,  daughter of  Stephen & Matilda North   Died  Sept. 30, 1835

                                    Aged 4  months

     “                  Albert  &  Irene North’s son and daughter,  Born and Died  May 5, 1821

     “                  Edwin, son of Albert and Irene,  Died March 4, 1830,  Age 11 months

     “                  Lucy Lovisa,   daughter of Stephen & Patience,  Died March 11, 1829

                                      Age 4 weeks

NORTHRUP   James   Died  Oct. 1, 1859,  Age 64 years

     “                  Mary Ann,  wife of William and former wife of George Johnson,  Died

                                    Oct.19. 1874  Age 59 years  6 months  (buried with Johnsons)

 

 
PARSHALL    Sabrina,  wife of John Parshall   Died Aug. 28, 1852

 

PASHLEY       Eunice, daughter of Samuel and Ann,  Died May 11, 1856  Age 26 years

 

PAUL              Elizabeth  Born March 26, 1737.  Died  Oct.18, 1825 in her 89th year

 

PEASE            Lovina,  wife of Robert Pease   Died Dec.11, 1866  Age 56 years

 

PECK              Cynthia    Died  May 11, 1810  in her 30th year

     “                  Jacob   Died  March 1, 1813  Age 40 years

     “                  Mercy, wife of Jacob,  Died  Feb.15, 1840/1  Age  67 years

 

PRESTON       Daniel,   Died Aug.23, 1849   Age 90 years, 3 months

     “                  Daniel, Jr.  Born  April 22, 1810   Died June 27, 1885

     “                  Esther,  wife of Daniel   Died  Nov. 27, 1862

     “                  Rufus,   Died  March 25, 1837  Age     years, 2 months

     “                  Olive,  wife of Rufus,   Died July 12, 1830,  Age 32 years,  2 months

 

REXFORD      Annis, wife of Ensign Rexford   Died  May 10, 1857?   Age 88 years

     “                  Ensign   Died June 7, 1836  73 years

     “                  Jared    Died Feb. 12, 1852  Age  78 years

     “                  Phebe,  wife of Jared    Died  June 6, 1848   Age 76 years

     “                  Sylvester   Died  Sept. 5, 1818   Age 59 years

     “                  Susan,  wife of Sylvester   Died       12, 1857  

 

ROBERTS       George,  Born , Conn., April 16, 1765   Died Sept. 7, 1843

     “                  Alice METCALF, wife of George Roberts  Born  at Leb. Ct.   Feb.22, 
1769   Died  Oct. 23, 1824

     “                  Lavina A,  Born  March 26, 1804   Died  June  21, 1890

     “                  Horace Knight Roberts,  Born Dec. 21, 1808    Died Sept. 18, 1843

     “                  Sible,  Born  Feb.7, 1793   Died  March 1, 1880

     “                  Henry,  Born  March 10, 1806  Died  July 15, 1878  Buried at Westford

     “                  Oron,  Born  April 29, 1802   Died  Oct. 13, 1861  Buried at Westford

     “                  Alice,  Born June 13, 1791  Died March 14, 1853  Buried :Lakewood Cem

     “                  Sophia,  Born  Oct.17, 1794  Died Aug.27, 1857  Buried Floyd,  Iowa

     “                  Sally  Born  July 9, 1797  Died  July 18, 1831  Buried Vienna, NY

     “                  George W  Born May 6, 1800   Died June 11, 1887

 

ROCKWELL  John     Died  July 19, 1827   70 years 

     “                  Betty,  wife of John   Died  Aug. 12, 1821  in her 61 year

     “                  Charlotte, dau of John and Betty   Died Oct.21, 1820  in her 12th year

     “                  Betsey,   Died April 12, 1875   Age 80 years

     “                  Eliza,   Died 1823 in her 23rd year

 

RUSSELL        Gideon,   Died  Nov.3,1859   Age 70 years

     “                  Catherine,  Died  March 19, 1855  in her 33d year

 

RUTTENBER   William,   Died  Nov. 20, 1850  Age 87 years

     “                  Kezia,  wife of William   Died May 10, 1834   40/42 years

     “                  Dorothy Maria, dau of William   Died April  1840  Age 35 years

     “                  Dorothy, wife of William   Died  Jan.10, 1835,  61 years

 

SABIN                        Hannah, wife of Deacon Timothy Sabin   Died  Jan.31, 1810   50 years

 

SCOTT            Alice,  mother of Samuel   Born 1790    Died  1846

     “                  Cylon,   Died  Aug.17, 1838,  child of Samuel and Alice Scott

     “                  John P   Born  Jan.17, 1843   Died March 18, 1843, son of S & A Scott

     “                  Leila    Born  June 22, 1853  Died  May 18, 1854, child of S & A Scott

     “                  Luzerne   Born March 8, 1855  Died  Oct.9, 1865,    “     “   “     “    “

 

SNELL            Mary,  dau of Menzo  &  Jenett Snell   Died Sept.18, 1861   Age 4 years

 

SPRAGUE       Abiah    Died 1796

     “                  Captain Joseph,   Born R.I  1738   Died Otsego  March  14, 1809

     “                  Phyllis,  wife of Capt. John,   Died July 10, 1814   Age 70 years

     “                  Mary,  dau. of Joseph & Mary Sprague   Died. Oct, 28, 1815   5 years

     “                  Rachael Ann,  dau of Joseph & Mary,  Died June 27, 1819  12 years

     “                  Sarah   Died March 8, 1797  Age 1 year, 8 months and 20 days

 

STEERE          Betsy,   Died Oct. 21, 1838

 

STEWART      Lydia,  wife of David Stewart   Died Sept.6, 1845  Age 52 years

     “                  Lovina D  dau of David and Lydia Stewart   Died  1813

 

 

 

TANNER        Mary Ann  dau of Peabody & Roxanna Tanner   Died Oct.10, 1839

                                    Age 7 years, 5 months and 3 days

THOMPSON  Clarissa, wife of John H. Thompson   Died Feb.11, 1848  Age 46 years

     “                  Ann Eliza, dau. of John H. & Clarissa Thompson   Died Feb.5, 1840, 

                                    Age 3 years

TOBEY           Lucy, wife of Noah Tobey   Died June 9, 1835  Age 23 years, 3 mo, 3 d

 

TODD             Benjamin,    Died  Aug.9, 1814,  27 years

 

TUTTLE          Chester    1828  -  1900

     “                  Eva, wife of John Tuttle  1806 - 1867

 

 

VROMAN       Harry    April 12, 1895 - Aug.29, 1915

 

 

WADE Daughter of Asahel and Elizabeth Wade,   Died Oct. 1817

 

WALDBY       Sarah, wife of William Waldby, Sr.,  Died Aug.14, 1829  Age 59

     “                  William,   Died May 23, 1829   Age 12 years

     “                  William, Sr.,    Died Dec.22, 1825

 

WELCH          Abigail L   Died Sept.16, 1815   Age 31 years

 

WENTWORTH  Elisha   Died Nov.20, 1848   Age 48 years

     “                  Lucy BROCKWAY,  wife of Elisha Wentworth   Died Novc.30, 1882  

                                    Age 72 years, 9 months & 29 days

 

WHIPPLE       Eliza,   Died  Dec.25, 1825

 

WILLIAMS     Eliphalet,   Died June 7, 1817  in his 45th year

     “                  Mary Russell, dau of Eliphalet and Susanna Williams  Died March 21,

                                    1841   Age 25

     “                  Electa Ann  dau of  John & Eliza Williams, adopted dau of R.& M

                                    .Brownell.   Died Dec.19, 1855  Age 12 years, 1 month, 1 day

     “                  Eliza Ann, wife of John B.Williams   Died March 11, 1844  Age 19 years

     “                  Celestia A.   July 11, 1857  -  May 16, 1861

     “                  Leverett B   Oct.13, 1851 -  Nov.2, 1851

     “                  Silas,  Died Feb.26, 1852    in 82d year

     “                  Keziah, wife of Silas   Died Nov.8, 1857

     “                  Harley,  1824 - 1827

     “                  Mary, wife of William Williams  Died Dec.15, 1861  in her 86th year

     “                  Mary M., dau of William and Mary,  Died Aug.21, 1828,  Age 6 yrs, 2 mo

     “                  John   Died  June 6, 1852

     “                  Paulina,  wife of John  C   Died  Sept.4, 1839

     “                  Margaret,   Died  Jan.6, 1870

Otsego County Cemetery Index Page

Otsego County Home Page